• Home
  • Blog
  • Scholarship
    • English Literature >
      • Revisiting Brideshead
    • Theology >
      • Making Friends with Mammon
      • Live Action Debate
      • Quid Est Caritas?
    • G.K. Chesterton >
      • Orthodoxy Study Guide
      • George Bernard Shaw
      • Evelyn Waugh and GKC: The Twitch Upon the Thread
      • Argue, Don't Quarrel
      • Arena - Annotations
    • Catholic Social Teaching & Distributism
  • Teaching
    • Teaching Philosophy
    • Teaching Artifacts >
      • Artifact #1
      • Artifact #2
      • Artifact #3
  • Activism
  • Bio/Resume/Contact
    • Resume
    • Contact Form
Joe Grabowski

The Consolations of Pedantry

The Not Too Personal Blog of Joseph L. Grabowski
Categories

All
Catholic Social Teaching
Catholic World Report
Chesterton
Distributism
Economics
Gilbert Magazine
Musings
Pro Life For A New Era
Published Articles
Q&A
Quotations
The Catholic Herald
The Stream

Archive Links

March 2025
May 2024
January 2024
March 2023
November 2022
July 2022
June 2022
May 2022
June 2021
April 2021
March 2021
February 2021
December 2020
November 2020
September 2019
August 2019
June 2017
April 2017

Three Questions on Distributism - Question 3

9/28/2019

Comments

 
Continued from Question 1 and Question 2.

I have read that Distributism is anti-mass production. Is this true? If so, what model does Distributism put forward for developing complex machines, medicines, and other products reliably and affordably?
This, too, like the former, is a very good question, precisely because it seems simple but belies a great deal of complexity. 
 
Once again, some Distributists, encountering this question, might simply point out that there are models of mass production organized along Distributist principles, perhaps most notably such as the Mondragon Cooperative in the Basque Region of Spain. 
 
But once again, I tend to feel that such an answer is too facile: at least in my mind, lingering implications of the question remain even after pointing out that Distributism can work with large-scale production.

I think there are philosophical correlations here to what I wrote about in the previous answer. Just as wasteful obsolescence has real-world consequences that market mechanisms alone don't seem fully 
to account for, so too most markets involving mass production have what are called "externalized costs" that seem bound up with ethical/socio-political questions, and can't be resolved simply by economic analysis. 

Read More
Comments

Three Questions on Distributism - Question 2

9/28/2019

Comments

 
Continued from Question 1.

​Distributism believes businesses and individuals will flourish if the means of production is well spread; therefore, it believes that control of assets by the few is to be avoided. Socialism professes the opposite, believing there should be no private property, while Capitalism can lead to Oligarchy or Corporatism if left unchecked. On the other hand, Capitalism, when at its best, promotes people to innovate and out compete others either by making a new or better product or making a product better. How does Distributism promote innovation and prevent Oligarchy? At what point does a business become to big? Am I correct in guessing that American anti-trust laws are a form of Distributism?
I addressed some of this in the preceding, but this is a good question in its particulars.

To answer the ultimate question, I'd say that, yes, anti-trust laws and regulations preventing effective monopolies certainly are implicitly in line with Distributism.

On the topic of innovation and competition, though...

Read More
Comments

Three Questions on Distributism - Question 1

9/27/2019

Comments

 
A questioner wrote to me with three questions following my recent podcast recording on Distributism, and as I took some time to answer them and thought them generally useful basic questions on the subject, I decided I'd post them with the answers I gave here. 

Here follows the first question and its answer; questions 2 and 3 with their respective answers will be posted separately. Be not faint of heart, this is the longest answer by a good margin, but also the most fundamental question.

​Enjoy!

Read More
Comments

    Categories

    All
    Catholic Social Teaching
    Catholic World Report
    Chesterton
    Distributism
    Economics
    Gilbert Magazine
    Musings
    Pro Life For A New Era
    Published Articles
    Q&A
    Quotations
    The Catholic Herald
    The Stream

    Archives

    March 2025
    May 2024
    January 2024
    March 2023
    November 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    June 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    September 2019
    August 2019
    June 2017
    April 2017

    Old Site

    To visit my old blog site, please click here.

    RSS Feed

HOME
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Scholarship
    • English Literature >
      • Revisiting Brideshead
    • Theology >
      • Making Friends with Mammon
      • Live Action Debate
      • Quid Est Caritas?
    • G.K. Chesterton >
      • Orthodoxy Study Guide
      • George Bernard Shaw
      • Evelyn Waugh and GKC: The Twitch Upon the Thread
      • Argue, Don't Quarrel
      • Arena - Annotations
    • Catholic Social Teaching & Distributism
  • Teaching
    • Teaching Philosophy
    • Teaching Artifacts >
      • Artifact #1
      • Artifact #2
      • Artifact #3
  • Activism
  • Bio/Resume/Contact
    • Resume
    • Contact Form